10.10.11

Mi reseña de Betibú, de Claudia Piñeiro


Claudia Piñeiro returns to the scene of the crime

Claudia Piñeiro has established herself as one of the key names in Argentine literature, as far as readers are concerned, riding on a series of fortunate events: the runaway hit of Las viudas de los jueves (Clarín Novel Award 2005, international bestseller, adapted into a blockbuster film) followed by a successful reissue of her previous thriller Tuya, and then the critically acclaimed Elena sabe and the awarded Las grietas de Jara. Now the hat trick is complete with another bestseller, Betibú.
This first paragraph begs for the followup “a writer struck on a formula for bestsellers and is riding it big time,” if it weren’t for the fact that it is actually difficult to find that many similarities between the books. Las viudas de los jueves struck gold with its detective story set in the secret spaces of a gated community (with plot sometimes yielding to the portrayal of the infamous life of the rich and secluded, a major part of the book’s appeal), but Elena sabe was more about disease than crime and Las grietas de Jara was more about the growing pains of its middle-aged protagonist than the suspense of its enigmas. She does perform clever variations of the crime fiction pattern, with shades of noir even, and she develops in all these books an evolving craft for fleshing out interesting characters and weaving plots full of twists and turns in all the right places, but that is where similarities end, and in all other respects her writing is uncompromising – say what you want about it, but it is neither copycat nor written to please. And yet, readers can’t get enough of her. In Argentine literature, this is as rare as a unicorn playing jazz guitar. In a tutu. On the moon.
Betibú is rare, also, because Piñeiro makes her career and reputation a centerpiece in the story through Nurit Iscar (a strange name indeed, and an anagram for “satiric run”, but if there is a meaning behind it Piñeiro is yet to reveal it), “the queen of detective fiction,” a washed-out crime novelist who stopped writing after a catastrophic attempt at a romantic tale and a scathing review it got in El Tribuno, the country’s leading newspaper. The setting of the story, which begins with an apparent suicide in a country club (the husband of a woman who had been murdered on the same house, a not-at-all-veiled allusion to the García Belsunce case) and takes place mostly within its well-guarded boundaries, also looks back on Las viudas de los jueves, but reverts the perspective: this time, the outsiders are looking in and treading foreign ground as workers or temporary guests which are not used to the Kafkaesque security routines, feel baffled by the mechanics of the lifestyle and cannot fully grasp the web of prejudice and perverseness behind it all.
The plot revolves around those deaths and the dark secrets behind them, but also about El Tribuno and the role of the press. An old-school crime journalist, Jaime Brena, has been demoted to writing absurd stories on “general interest” trivia, and his role is now filled by an unnamed youngblood who knows everything about Google and nothing about police sources and digging up stories beyond the official version. When the suicide makes headlines, Brena watches from the sidelines as the kid botches the coverage of a case he had first investigated. Nurit is then called by the newspaper’s sinister editor (and her former lover) to set up shop at a loaned house inside the country club and write a daily feature on the case, as a crime novelist. Power games will unfold, along with discussions on leather-sole vs. online journalism, how information gets thwarted and slanted, what interests get in the way of its dissemination and how crime stories transmogrify in a country where corruption rules and there are essentially no clean guys.
At first sight, one feels tempted to think that Piñeiro is not a stylist – her prose does not offer those gleaming passages that leave you in awe. But then you realize that her writing just flows, and that you have devoured the 345 pages (generous type, spacing and margins lend a helping hand here) in a couple of days. This happens only when a story grabs you by the neck and is delivered in a language that works for the tale rather than for its own sake, and is the mark of an author confident enough to rely more on the mechanics of storytelling than the fireworks of verbal flare.
But it is not all narrative muscle here: the story has a heart as big as a house, and is filled with humour – some of it wry, much of it at the expense of Piñeiro and the literary scene (including a delightful jab at a particularly dimwitted so-called book reviewer). It is clear that the writer is exorcizing some of her own demons in the figure of Nurit Iscar and several other features of the book, but she pulls it off without putting herself on the spot or being self-condescending and never lets herself get in the way of her novel – another jazz-playing unicorn in a literary scene so utterly dominated by mountain-sized egos. The book does slacken in some chapters burdened with too much exposition (although there is much effort put on making that exposition integral to the plot) and the retelling of a hazy marihuana night is not that satisfactory, but it is a solid read regardless.
Claudia Piñeiro’s writing career, which actually started in the early 90s when she was a young and dissatisfied corporate accountant, gained momentum a decade later in her mid-40s, and the results speak for themselves. If attention has been put in recent years on young writers and some biographical gimmicks (He works on TV and discovered spirituality! She was an anorexic!), her meteoric rise reminds us that, deep down, it’s all about the story and how well you tell it, and that certain qualities in writers must be allowed to blossom if the writing is to stand on its own merits.
Publicada en el Buenos Aires Herald el 16 de septiembre de 2011

Mi reseña de Kryptonita, de Leonardo Oyola


What if...?

Kryptonita, by Leonardo Oyola. Random House Mondadori.

It’s night in the emergency room of the Paroissien hospital in Isidro Casanova, a nasty BA suburb. A nochero (the “unofficial” doctors who for a price cover the shifts of the professionals who are supposed to be on duty) is about to end his third day on his feet and can think of nothing but going home and swallowing a handful of pills to get him into a sleep that is anything but peaceful. It has been an eventful night, but it is about to get worse: a patient comes in with a strange wound on his back and several dangerous friends in tow. It is Nafta Súper, one of the most dangerous thugs in the area, and his friends are the other members of his gang. The ER is cleared of patients and doctors, the police surrounds the hospital, and the doctor is given clear instructions: keep Nafta Súper alive until daybreak, or you’re dead. But Nafta Súper is no ordinary human... in fact, neither of his friends is.
“Elseworlds” are a well-established tradition in comics and graphic novels, one which sets known heroes in alternative settings (a swashbuckling pirate Batman, Superman as Tarzan, Green Lantern in the Far West, etc.), and Leonardo Oyola’s Kryptonita is an open tribute to superheroes through a very Argentine elseworld. Here, Nafta Súper is Superman and his ‘associates’ are members of the League of Justice (Wonder Woman, Batman, Green Lantern, etc.). There are reconstructions of their backstories, and even retellings of some of their most famous adventures (like the 1992 Death of Superman DC series), and the representation is true even for their rivalries and secret weaknesses.
This is but one of the pop references in the novel, full of allusions to 1980s rock/pop and cumbia and suburban street codes. For that alone, this would be a rarity in a literary world that has more knowledge of French philosophers than the inside of a villa miseria. But, for Oyola (the author of Chamamé, Gólgota and Siete y el tigre harapiento, among others) you could call it par for the course: he specializes in fast-paced suburban stories where crime, action and violence meet fantasy and magic, steeped in an atmosphere of pop and rock references and strong characters with very deep roots in the real world. He has been called a noir novelist, and has in fact won the top prize at Gijón’s Semana Negra in Spain, but his palette (albeit dark) has many more shades than that.
And Kryptonita is the perfect example, a stew where all the ingredients could only come from his pen. The story is straightforward (Nafta Súper has been betrayed by his nemesis, they must get through the night fighting the police and so on), but the fact that there is “something else” to these characters turns it into something else. By the same token, he is turning the tables on the old dilemma of Argentine crime fiction, which is by definition noir because down here cops, criminals, judges and Government are hard to tell from one another (as in El secreto de sus ojos or Claudia Piñeiro’s Betibú, to name but two recent popular examples that put this conundrum up front and centre): if this is what happens with local detectives, what would happen to an Argentine superhero? If you take Krypton’s last son out of Smallville, will he grow righteous and uphold the law? Or will he make his own? For this discovery alone, and for bringing this into a literary arena that has no Michael Chabons to embrace its pop heroes, this is a book worth reading.
But, fast-paced and hardhitting and inventive as the stories are, there are moments when the tale breaks loose and flies away from Oyola’s hands, burdening a plotline that would benefit from being straight and fast as an arrow with lengthy detours into flashbacks and backstory. The detours themselves are gripping, the fictional universe is solid and the voices he uses to tell them are worth exploring, but when several 10-page chapters take you away from the main plot in a 215-page novel there comes a point when the reader says “this is good stuff, but take us back to the dying man on the surgery table and the bonaerense cops armed to the teeth outside.”
If the writer is the father of the novel, you could say that at times Oyola is an over-indulgent dad who cannot get enough of his talented kid and refuses to rein them in or edit the output. And a wild imagination telling a wild tale needs a steady hand to control it and bring it into shape, or the force of the narrative potential ends up working against the effectiveness of the story itself: if Tolkien left so many notebooks with unfinished side stories of the Middle Earth and Susannah Clarke featured the world of Jonathan Strange & Mr. Norrel in some short stories of The Ladies of Grace Adieu, it was because they could see the potential of the imaginary world they had created but were also aware that all those stories did not fit in the framework of the novels (and those were much lengthier books than Kryptonita).
It must be said, too, that this would have been an area for a good editor to finetune. A proper editor would have helped tighten the narrative strings for Oyola’s powerful prose and explosive imagination to come to its fullest, but, alas, the editing work on this edition is borderline shoddy, to the point of spelling howlers such as “exploción” (page 175) making it to the printed page. Unfortunately, a cursory glance at another September release from the same publisher shows similar flaws, which do not speak of the writer (errors happen) but do speak to the fact that someone in that publishing house is asleep at the wheel (they are there to stop the errors from making it into bookstores).
But none of this takes away from the fact that this is a remarkable book, one that cries for relatives: if this were the first of its kind and we could one day fill a shelf with likeminded stories by Oyola and other Argentine writers, I for one would call myself a happy reader and Argentine literature would be much the richer. This is not Michael Chabon’s The Amazing Adventures of Kavalier & Klay yet, not quite Neil Gaiman’s American Gods, but it’s a very good first step in that most promising direction.
Publicada en el Buenos Aires Herald el 30 de septiembre de 2011

3.7.11

To e- or not to e-

Two UK experts on digital publishing talk about the present and future of ebooks


You and I both know that the days of the newspaper, as in the loose bundle of sheets you're holding in your hands right now, are counted. In fact you may already be reading this on your computer screen. And most people do not lose too much sleep over that fact (unless you happen to work in a newsroom...). And yet, when the shadow of extinction hovers over books matters get a lot more thorny. And yet, things like Amazon's Kindle and Apple's iPad, or even smartphones and netbooks, are being heralded by some as “book killers.” The latest fad? A new world? Countdown for our beloved codex?
Peter Collingridge and George Walkley are certainly two of the right people to ask. Collingridge is currently at the helm of Enhanced Editions, a publisher specializing in digital projects for the iPhone and iPad that augment the reading experience: at the push of a finger, the text on the screen (and it could be Charles Dickens, or Nick Cave, or Philip Pullman, or even Stephen King) may be accompanied by the voice of the author reading the book, or a soundtrack, or a short video that complements a scene. Walkley is responsible for the digital division of the Hachette UK group. An entrepreneur on the cutting edge of reinventing the reading experience and the captain of a fleet of 40,000 titles on the treacherous seas of digital, two different approaches and the same passion for books. And, just to ease your angst, yes, they had their iPhones and Macbooks on the table as we spoke, but also a couple old-fashioned hardcovers.

What attitudes towards digital publishing did you find among local publishers?
Peter Collingridge: What's interesting is the interest more than what we've seen. There's very much a sense from publishers and public that this is coming, but it's like an early warning – even in Britain, electronic reading is a very small percentage of the market compared to what it is in the US.
George Walkley: This Book Fair reminded me of the London Book Fair a year ago. The conversations were on the whole about six months behind where we are in Britain. We've also met some people who are doing more advanced things, so the market is here but not evenly distributed yet.
PC: There's also a sense that's what's happening will certainly affect Argentina but will also have a wider impact on Latin America and Spanish-language publishing as well. An extremely literate country such as Argentina is going to have its own rate of adoption, but how that affects the Spanish language industry is gonna be huge.

Being six months ahead of our learning curve, what's coming here next?
GW: We were having these same conversations until last August, when the Kindle was officially launched in the UK and they began marketing it. By the first week of December it was very difficult to go anywhere without seeing adverts for the Kindle – and I remember coming home after Christmas and every train I rode, every public place I visited was full of Kindles, it suddenly seemed to have exploded and there was this mass market moment.
PC: That, and also the announcement and launch of the iPad. A lot of their marketing was visualizing people reading. Apple and Amazon's aggressive marketing was the tipping point in reading: it became mainstream. I was in Italy, Russia and Spain in the last six months, and without a Kindle it is definitely slower to adopt because the iPad is a general entertainment device whereas the Kindle does one thing very well. The Kindle is driving 60 or 70 percent of electronic reading.

And yet your company is betting on a much more sophisticated reading experience than what the Kindle offers.
PC: We are pretty pragmatic about that. We invested in apps, but we've also done projects which are purely for Kindle, and what we're very interested in is understanding the new reader and what this new reader likes, whether they want audio and video or just very beautiful text or nothing at all, but also exploring how ebooks are sold, recommended, discussed, shared, the whole ecosystem.

How does a mass market publisher like Hachette deal with these two different devices?
GW: There are two layers here: the product level and the platform level. On the product level, 99 percent of what we sell in both the US and UK are very straightforward e-books, a replication of the print book with very few enhancements. That's what consumers are buying in large quantities, and so our immediate focus has been on getting a very broad range of those available. Having said that, we do expect consumers' taste to change over time, and this is where we came up with a platform: we started off with simple platforms that did one thing, but increasingly now there are also extras on the side like social features, being able to recommend a quote from the book on Facebook, and we see those becoming more important. The majority of e-readers now have a network connection, can connect to social networks and do all of those interesting things. In time, I think, the sort of work Peter's company does will become much more normal and will be seen as the rule rather than the exception. We've done projects like that and will continue to experiment, but also as a very commercial house we keep an eye on where the mass market is, where we can get sales in the short to medium term while we plan innovation for the medium to long term. Five years from now multimedia will be much more accepted and people won't see it as much of an interruption. In the past we've seen really good multimedia alongside the text and sometimes that was seen as an interruption and something readers did not want it. But we're moving to a world of richer, across-platform experiences: I've seen research on how teenagers and young people consume television, and the interesting thing is that they check social networks while they're watching. That's a change that happened to TV over a 10-year period, and over time I think people will read and use social media while they read.

This seems like a high-speed replica of the natural process of reading a book and talking it over with friends, a reading circle, etc... Is this speeding up creating something new?
PC: Everybody does things at their own pace – I'm currently reading about 7 or 8 books at different speeds, some of which I'll finish, some of which I won't. I just signed up to a private feature of a new social reading service which allows me to share that reading with my friends – that's built on platforms rather than products. The sort of stuff that we're doing and the social things are currently very much on the outer edges and the innovating end of publishing, but companies like Apple, Amazon and Google do innovating stuff very very quickly and with it reach millions and millions of people.

I was thinking of the difference between the Alice in Wonderland app on the iPad and the enhanced editions you do: Alice feels like a game with text more than a book.
PC: It's a wonderful game, but if you've ever given it to a child they play the game and don't read the book. With us, what we want to do is to not distract the reading experience but take people deeper into it. Having the author read the book to you in their own voice, in the case of the Nick Cave book having a soundtrack, all of that stuff is meant not to add bells and whistles onto a work of art but to take you deeper into the work. At a time where consumers' attention is under assault from so many different media at the same time, reading (which has always been seen as a luxury pursuit) will manifest itself in interesting ways.

Working for a mass publisher, how do you sell the notion that we've published this book in print, it's sold well, but now we have to do all this other work for the electronic edition?
GW: Editors and publishers are pragmatic people, they see that there's a new market and they want their books and their authors to be part of that market. Taking our existing list and making it available for e-readers is straightforward: it's an issue of volume and engineering but it's not fundamentally difficult. With the more enhanced material, we take a very selective view. We have about 40,000 titles in our care, of which so far 6,000 are available as straightforward e-books and in time that will rise to 20,000. We're doing several thousand standard e-books a year, while we might do a dozen enhanced projects in that period. We pre-select the projects carefully, only those where the author and the editor will be supportive, and it's generally an easy sell because they're keen by definition.
PC: We don't see what goes on behind the scenes, but people who contact us tend to be editors and publishers. In the past it was marketing directors, but now there's an enthusiasm for digital coming from the editorial department and that's a very welcome change because those who are responsible for the creative direction of the book will also be safeguarding its transition to digital.
GW: The publishing business is fundamentally one of relationships – our relationship with the reader, our relationship with Amazon or Apple, but mostly about our relationship to the author, and in most cases that relationship is embodied by the editor. A publisher recently told me he's currently employing more editors now than at any time in his company's history. This is a challenge for the industry and it's changing many things about the way we conceive the book and the way we're distributing the book itself, but very fundamentally it's a huge opportunity to do very interesting things with books, to take them to wider audiences.

How about an author like Henry James? Would you do an enhanced version of that?
PC: I wouldn't do that with Henry James. There are some enhanced ebooks which depend heavily on dramatizations: unless you are Ang Lee and you have his budget and production, it's just gonna be crap and really awkward. But there are interventions that could be made along the lines of a slightly more modern version of the introductions to the classic texts where the publisher curates a set of supporting material which goes into the contents of the book: the text, a version of The Turn of the Screw film with Nicole Kidman, the review of the time, social reading groups, a sort of optional multimedia annotation with things like “if you like this book you may like this other book by Guy de Maupassant” and introduce the first chapter of the book, things a bit more crazy than when you're limited by the number of pages you can print. Yet, a lightness of touch in enhancement is very important. Enhancement and distraction are two different things. One of the different challenges as an industry is how to sustain the interest of a new generation of readers courted by very appealing media.
GW: We're very used to the idea of our competitors being Random House or Harper Collins or Penguin: it's a change in mindset to think that our competitors are Angry Birds and Twitter and YouTube and email.

Are you jumping on Angry Bird land when you jump on the device?
PC: Yes, but we capture data from the use of our applications and we know that readers prefer audio to video – video in e-books is not very interesting to them, but the author reading to them is by far the most popular feature we have. The average time that any user spends in an app is about 30 seconds. In our applications on the iPad it is 30 minutes, but on the iPhone it's over an hour and 10 minutes. That demonstrates two things. Firstly, that people still like to read for relatively significant increments of time. But also, that they are distracted more on the iPad – more things to do, whereas on the iPhone you're much more conscious of having to switch between things. When you're on the iPad you're always thinking “what shall I do next?”.
GW: There's also this thing that my iPhone literally never leaves my side, but I don't always have my iPad with me. The iPhone is a very pleasant companion, so it's quite easy to spend a lot of time with it.
PC: The genesis of our company came from having an iPhone and finding that I was using it to read in the moments when I didn't have a book with me but I had nothing else to do – on the bus, the tube, the bank.

It's easy to get tangled on the bells and whistles: what do you want the apps to feel like?
PC: We don't want to reproduce the book in a kitsch: iBook on iPad is a kitsch, with side pages and the flipping gesture to turn pages. We rejected that, but we kept on to the better principles of the book: very elegant typography, and that the design should be invisible – as soon as you notice the interface is there, you've failed. User feedback is that they like flipping pages, but other feedback says that flipping pages is very tiresome because the screen size on a phone is little more than a paragraph.

Do you think there will be a moment where authors start thinking in terms of digital media from the beginning?
GW: Yes. There are electronic publishers who are thinking in bold ways, people in the academic sector who think about interactive narrative and have done a lot of work on this. It is primarily about the book and the text now, but I see the line being blurred between forms of media. Movie and TV companies have done transmedia stuff for shows like Heroes, Lost and Doctor Who: fantastic interactive narratives. But this is not going to come mostly from publishers. We are working with fantastically talented people who come up with lots of things, and what we help do is add value, help them deliver it, bring resources and scale, and to be blunt finance them. But we're not fundamentally the creative originators.

Amazon was at first a book company, but Apple and Google were never it. How do these players change the game?
GW: I'm a card-carrying Amazon fan in terms of the consumer experience, they do retail like no one else. They started in books, whereas Google and Amazon are newer players in the book world but they've dealt with other media so they're not completely unfamiliar with it. It's exciting to look at the pure start-ups who are coming in without any baggage of preconceived wisdom – from the mobile phone world, from games.

How about having only one distributor, in the case of the Apple store? Has it ever been a problem?
PC: Apple is very exacting technically and in terms of content about what goes on the store. We've had some hairy moments... Nick Cave's The Death of Bunny Munro is about sex and drugs and rock'n'roll – it took them three weeks to approve the iPhone app, but it felt like six months, we were very worried that it was going to get rejected. It was our first app, we tried to coincide the launch with a tour Nick Cave was doing at the same time, that was tough. Somebody who works in publishing in the US described it as farming on the side of a volcano, it's very fertile when you're there but something could happen: if they decide they're gonna do books now and all other books are out of the Apple Stores, for instance. It's the deal, we signed up the terms and conditions... One of the new complications of selling apps is that suddenly content which had never had any kind of level censorship at all was arbitrarily being assigned age ratings through a series of 12 questions and the answers were way too important.

Imagine you wake up 10 years from now and you want to access some content that today we associate with a book. What do you see?
GW: More. More of everything. First of all, more books: in the US market, the number of books published has increased tenfold over an 8-year period, and the majority of the new books published have been self-published. There have been over a million new books published in the US last year, and the tendency is more books. There will of course be more formats, and I don't think there will be a hard and fast right format for a book, it will depend on the book in question, on its intended audience and its intended purpose. We will have a scale: on one end we will have multimedia experiences that may not look very much like a book, and at the other end we will have very traditional forms. Between the two there will be a range of things, we'll certainly see digital disproportionately replace paperbacks, mass-market books, airport books, books which are read once and tend not to be read again. We'll also see things like print on demand, straightforward e-books, enhanced e-books, and then multimedia. We'll also see more business models: straightforward sale, lending and renting, Spotify-like subscription models, bundles where I order a book online and while it is shipped I have access to a digital edition.
PC: I see Blade Runner. I see backstreet illegal dens of iniquity where you can get hardback printed books and collectors seen as perverts (laughs). I think we will see a cherishing of print and the tactile: I buy all my music on vynil, even though I have a Spotify account.
GW: There's a William Gibson line that I adore, “The future's here, it's just not evenly distributed”.
PC: Quite right. There is something Gibsonian in the idea of the bookshop selling rare, scarce items.

Every time you talk digital you also talk MP3 and piracy. What's your take on that?
GW: We see a lot of filesharing by consumers. As an industry, we have the luxury of looking at sister industries like music and film and learn lessons from them. I'm pleased to say we haven't gone down the route of litigating against individual consumers, which I'm not convinced is a sensible approach. There are two things I am absolutely certain of: the first is that there is absolutely no way of eradicating piracy and filesharing, and the second is that the most effective way we can reduce piracy is by providing a high-quality, convenient, easy to buy product. The fact is I can get my computer and get any book in the New York Times Top 10 in about five or ten minutes through a variety of websites – it may be a good quality file, it may be a bad quality file that's been badly scanned and even rekeyed, I have no guarantee of quality. If, on the other hand, I can go on my Kindle and 30 seconds later I can have a really good quality ebook...
PC: But in contrast, if you go to Amazon and you try to find those Top 10 books as a Kindle or iPad edition you might not find them.
GW: The industry has to make sure that those books are available legitimately. It's very interesting that the Harry Potter books still aren't available as legitimate e-books but it's a trivially easy exercise to get all of them. Frustrated availability and frustrated consumers is a big driver of filesharing. The onus is on publishers to get the e-books available, make sure that the quality is great (something that publishers have struggled with but we're getting better at), and make sure that the price is reasonable. In the UK we typically set the price of the e-book at about half the price of the book, so the consumer feels that it is treated like a book and they feel it's a reasonable amount to pay. I think asking, regardless of the actual cost structure of e-books, there's an expectation from the consumer of e-books to be cheaper than physical editions, and we have to understand that.
PC: If your books aren't available, you're missing out on a potential sale. If somebody really wants that book for their new iPad and they're not gonna buy a print edition, we're training them on how to pirate stuff so that the next time it becomes easier and easier. They wouldn't normally do that, but until there's an alternative they probably will – I've pirated stuff because it wasn't available. I went to Russia, and they're absolutely terrified of piracy, but the industry's really bad about making their product available to the point where they've cataclysmically destroyed their chances of being able to emerge from the position they're in. They've got a massively fragmented market, everybody knows where to get books illegally, and as a result the chances of popping the genie back in the bottle are very small. That's because they've been late at going digital and they failed to meet the demand of the consumers.
GW: It's very important that publishers don't succumb to the conceit that consumers are in love with the delivery format or the business model: they're in love with the experience of reading and the emotions and the knowledge they take from it, not with the collection of paper and glue.
PC: The people that are buying Kindles are not the early adopters, they are the ones who bought stacks of print books before.
Publicado en el Buenos Aires Herald el 2/7/2011

22.4.11

¿Las palabras discriminan?

Publiqué esta nota en la revista Newsweek en 2009, a partir de una campaña de difusión del INADI que tenía frases como "Son todos negros" y abajo el slogan "Las palabras discriminan". Ahora que está en cierto candelero el tema de la agresión/discriminación verbal, los contextos y las respuestas, aquí va de nuevo la nota. Debajo, el desgrabado con las declaraciones de la entonces titular del INADI y una lingüista que quedaron fuera de la nota por cuestiones de espacio.


El 14 de agosto el Inadi lanzó la campaña de prevención “Las palabras discriminan, no discrimines”. La campaña se desarrollará a lo largo de dos meses con carteles en transporte y vía pública, además de talleres en escuelas de todo el país y un trabajo conjunto con el Foro de la Discriminación en los Medios que culminará con la confección de manuales de estilo para periodistas para un tratamiento no discriminatorio de grupos vulnerabilizados.
¿Pero hasta qué punto es correcto afirmar que las palabras discriminan? ¿La discriminación se halla en ciertas expresiones, o éstas son emergentes de ideas que en cualquier otra formulación pueden ser igual de agresivas?
María José Lubertino, titular del INADI, limita el alcance de la consigna: “Las palabras no discriminan, las personas discriminan. Técnicamente no es correcto porque la frase en sí misma no priva de un derecho. Pero las palabras tienen poder en la construcción de imaginarios y de prácticas, no son neutras. Estas palabras construyen o reproducen en el lenguaje cotidiano los estereotipos que después degeneran en situaciones de violencia o de actos discriminatorios concretos. Algo puede ser dicho por error o ignorancia en algunos contextos, pero hay frases que no dan lugar a pensar que su utilización no sea descalificante y prejuiciosa.”
Para María del Carmen Grillo, docente investigadora de la Universidad Austral, licenciada en Letras y doctora en Comunicación, “todos coincidimos con que eso está mal, son términos despectivos y peyorativos, pero hay enclaves menos advertidos y más naturalizados que están tramitando prejuicios en otro nivel. Lo que habría que analizar son los presupuestos y los implícitos, no de palabras sueltas, sino de palabras puestas en encadenamientos. Estalla la Embajada de Israel y se habla de ‘víctimas inocentes’: la oposición y la diferencia están implícitos, porque si hay inocentes hay culpables, y eso me parece más temible”.
¿Viviríamos en un mundo mejor si elimináramos ciertas palabras? “Si se eliminan los términos está más limpito todo, pero algo se va a poner en ese lugar,” dice Grillo. Steven Pinker, el autor de “El instinto del lenguaje”, llama “la rueda del eufemismo” al proceso por el que los eufemismos absorben las connotaciones de las palabras que reemplazaban: “mover el vientre” e “ir de cuerpo” resultan hoy tan revulsivas como dentro de unos años lo será nuestro “tránsito lento”. La manía estadounidense de generar eufemismos no parece haber evitado que en estas elecciones muchos votantes rechacen visceralmente a un candidato negro (perdón, afroamericano).
Pero, como señala Lubertino, “en muchos casos es imprescindible el reemplazo de un término por otro cuando los colectivos han manifestado que no les da lo mismo”. La evolución de “sidoso” a “portador de SIDA” a “persona que vive con VIH” no es un mero reemplazo de términos sino un reconocimiento a la sensibilidad del grupo y a su propia elaboración teórica, al igual que el uso de “pueblos originarios” en lugar de “aborígenes” o “indios”. 


Lubertino
Nosotros trabajamos con denuncias y atendemos a las víctimas cuando hay una situación concreta con una persona que comete un acto discriminatorio identificado y que implica un cercenamiento de un derecho o la exclusión de un bien o un servicio para la persona que en base al estereotipo es excluida. Recibimos permanentemente llamadas y denuncias por situaciones que no tienen entidad de acto discriminatorio, porque no implican la privación de un derecho, pero sí un hostigamiento, maltrato sistemático en lugar de trabajo, en escuelas o situaciones de vida cotidiana y de calle.
Tomamos frases estereotipantes e injuriantes para grupos colectivos vulnerabilizados o discriminados por género, diversidad sexual, nacionalidad, color de piel, aspecto físico, obesidad, y lo planteamos con las frases más repetidas en nuestro sondeo, que tienen que ver con estereotipos y lo que hacen es transmitir prejuicios que en algunos contextos son insultos discriminatorios y que en otros contextos refuerzan la reproducción de estereotipos y prejuicios que desembocan muchas veces en actos discriminatorios que afectan derechos de las personas.
Una campaña muy agresiva.
Una manera de expresar que esas palabras generan y reproducen estereotipos. Las palabras no discriminan, las personas discriminan. Técnicamente no es correcto decir que las palabras discriminan porque la frase en sí misma no priva de un derecho – es una abstracción, una licencia literaria decirlo de esta manera.
Las palabras son violentas: la violencia verbal que cargan estas palabras genera una clasificación, una tipología de las personas, una jerarquía. Las personas somos todas diferentes. El Inadi promueve una cultura de la diversidad: lo que hace esta clasificación de las personas en función de alguna de sus características utilizadas de esta manera es establecer jerarquías sociales.
Talleres en las escuelas de todo el país. Foro de la Discriminación en los Medios con periodistas armando manuales de estilo para un tratamiento no discriminatorio de los grupos vulnerabilizados.
La jurisprudencia del Inadi era que los insultos no generaban un acto discriminatorio. Nosotros entendimos que hay situaciones en las que los insultos pueden ser discriminatorios porque se daba a partir de un insulto la privación de un derecho. Hay otras circunstancias en las que no, hay que ver la situación y el contexto – las palabras no pueden ser tomadas fuera de su contexto.
El otro día discutimos con Andy Kusnetzoff porque alguien puede decir “le compré al boliviano de la esquina”. Yo a veces discuto con la gente de los periódicos cuando ponen “trabajo en negro”, y yo les digo que la gente del foro de afrodescendientes discute, no está de acuerdo, se ofende cuando se pone esa frase. Después cuando dicen “Tres peruanos robaron”, las tapas de Crónica manifiestan la estereotipia, en otros casos la discusión con algunos periodistas y editores de policiales es que “estamos describiendo la situación, tenemos que dar la información”. En el uso del lenguaje el valor prioritario a tener en cuenta es la libertad de expresión, ahora, hay una restricción a la libertad de expresión que son las injurias y las calumnias y por otro lado el discurso de odio (hate speech) y las palabras de lucha (fighting words), una jurisprudencia de la Corte Suprema de los Estados Unidos que a veces ha sido tomada en la Argentina. La libertad de expresión no ampara el discurso de odio. Cualquiera puede odiar y no le podemos impedir que lo exprese, pero el discurso de odio que restringe la libertad de expresión es cuando efectivamente el grupo o la persona a la que ese discurso de odio se refiere puede tener un temor razonable a que esto se convierta en realidad. Cuando alguien dice “odio a los gallegos” en Argentina, por supuesto que es estereotipante, pero nadie puede pensar razonablemente que pueda correr riesgo su vida o que va a ser discriminado por ser gallego. Pero si alguien dijera “odio a los indígenas” sí tendríamos que prestar otro tipo de atención porque efectivamente e un grupo que está vulnerabilizado en sus derechos, no se cumplen sus derechos, hay datos concretos. Si alguien dice “odio a los católicos” no pasa lo mismo que si dice “odio a los judíos”. Esto lo tratamos de fijar en el dictamen de D’Elía: el Estado repudia todo discurso de odio, sea para mayorías o minorías, pero la intervención no puede ser la misma por parte de la Justicia o del Inadi.
No importa tanto la intención del que dice las palabras sino el umbral de las personas o el colectivo que es discriminado: estamos intentando sensibilizar y hacer docencia sobre una serie de temas con manuales y talleres. A las personas que viven con VIH primero se las llamó “sidosas” y después “portadores de SIDA”, pero las personas rechazan estas denominaciones por discriminatorias. Hay que escuchar al colectivo que a través de su trabajo y reflexión ha llegado a la denominación “personas que viven con VIH” considerando a todas las demás denominaciones discriminatorias. Los pueblos originarios se autodefinen como “pueblos o naciones originarias”, y desaprueban la palabra “indígena” porque entienden que refiere a “indigente”, y rechazan también los términos “primitivos” o “indios”. Algo puede ser dicho por error o ignorancia en algunos contextos, pero hay frases que no dan lugar a pensar que su utilización no sea descalificante y prejuiciosa. Cuando decís “dale mogólica”, negro villero o son bolitas muchas veces se aplica a personas que textualmente no lo son pero se lo utiliza como un insulto.
En muchos casos es imprescindible, necesario, conveniente el reemplazo de un término por otro cuando los colectivos han manifestado que no les da lo mismo. Las palabras también construyen imaginarios: no es lo mismo “sidoso” o “portador de SIDA” que “persona que vive con VIH”. Apuntamos a que se dejen de utilizar palabras que están ya descartadas por los propios colectivos y que se hable con corrección en relación a lios avances teóricos de los distintos colectivos, esa es una campaña educativa que tiene que ver con los usos del lenguaje en la escuela, en los medios de comunicación, en los avisos clasificados, etc. Estamos por otro lado promoviendo el uso de lenguaje de género no discriminatorio en la legislación. Hay una utilización de términos despectivamente discriminatorios aplicados a personas que no pertenecen a ese colectivo que genera y reproduce estos estereotipos, en la cancha de fútbol, como insulto cotidiano, y también estamos intentando combatir… de la misma manera que los chicos dejaron de tirar basura al piso o combaten a los padres que fuman, nosotros suponemos que podemos apuntar también a que tengan una conducta no discriminatoria, tienen que tomar conciencia de que hay un colectivo afectado por esta manera de hablar que no es necesariamente el compañero.
Estamos llamando el 26 de agosto a una reunión a todas las empresas de recursos humanos y las secciones de clasificados de los diarios y las webs de búsquedas laborales apuntando a la eliminación de los avisos clasificados de términos descriptivos que no tienen que ver con la idoneidad o la experiencia para la posición laboral que se solicita. Ahí también hay una serie de requerimientos que para ellos son descriptivos pero que claramente son limitativos del acceso al empleo. Estamos pidiendo que se redacten con perspectivas de género, que no tengan topes de edad, que no hagan una descripción física de las personas: lo único que se puede hacer en un aviso es la descripción del puesto de trabajo y la descripción de las capacidades, idoneidades y perfiles laborales requeridos, pero no exigir fotos.
Nosotros no queremos que alguien nos diga “el Inadi se ocupa de las palabras y no de los hechos reales”,  es un debate en paralelo.
Las palabras tienen poder en la construcción de imaginarios y de prácticas, no son neutras. Lo que elInadi está haciendo con esta licencia de decir “las palabras discriminan” es decir que estas palabras construyen o reproducen en el lenguaje cotidiano los estereotipos que después degeneran en situaciones de violencia o de actos discriminatorios concretos

Grillo

El signo siempre comporta una distinción, ese es su valor, la posibilidad de oponerse a otro signo dentro de un sistema. De ahí sale la potencia del signo. Hay que ver dónde está uno en relación con el signo. Un sujeto marca un signo.
Lo que habría que analizar son los presupuestos y los implícitos, no de palabras sueltas, sino de palabras puestas en encadenamientos. Estalla la Embajada de Israel y se habla de “víctimas inocentes”: la oposición y la diferencia están implícitos ahí, porque si hay inocentes hay culpables, y eso me parece más temible.
Se queda en el epifenómeno. Todos coincidimos con que eso está mal, son términos despectivos y peyorativos, pero no se juega sólo ahí. Hay enclaves menos advertidos y más naturalizados que están tramitando prejuicios en otro nivel, uno se queda en la superficie de “no decir bolita” pero por atrás hay un estereotipo que sigue siendo discriminatorio.
Si se eliminan los términos está más limpito todo, pero algo se va a poner en ese lugar. A veces se tramita desde lo sintáctico: ‘hubo una manifestación de Quebracho pero no hubo incidentes’ da por supuesto que cada vez que hay una marcha hay incidentes, o algo que señala Hugo Muleiro en Palabra por palabra, que cada vez que se usa la palabra ‘menor’ en los medios es para referirse a niños o adolescentes marginales que tienen que ver con la Justicia, nadie diría menor para referirse a los niños que van al zoológico o al Planetario. O cuando se dice ‘en un tiroteo murió por error una mujer que estaba en la calle’, ¿quiere decir que matar a ciertas personas es acertado? Es la perspectiva del asesino. Hay que estar atento sobre esas expresiones, en principio uno no pensaría que ahí hay discriminación y está. Va más allá de las palabras, depende de qué estás pensando cuando decís eso.
La discriminación es constitutiva del lenguaje, si no hubiera discriminación no se podrían decir cosas.
Si el gobierno de Estados Unidos dice que hubo ‘fuego amigo’, en ese eufemismo hay algo que no se quiere decir. Hay formas atenuadas de referirse al otro que son visiones del otro como alguien que hay que cuidar y que son visiones del otro como alguien a quien hay que proteger especialmente o cuidar, y el otro no quiere ser tratado como si fuera un infradotado. Hay que ver de todas maneras cómo ese sujeto quiere ser reconocido.
La palabra en relación con qué otras palabras está? No usemos palabras despectivas, son normas de urbanidad lingüística, pero el prejuicio está anidando en otro lugar: el lenguaje es una manifestación, pero la sola palabra despectiva no está tramitando eso, hay otras construcciones donde eso está.
Uno puede decir ‘negro’ y hablar de Usain Bolt, entonces los negros son fibrosos, son rápidos. La palabra ‘negro’ en determinados contextos puede ser bárbara, pero en una frase como ‘no es negro pero es negro de alma’ se trata de otra cosa. Se trata de qué palabra es, en relación con qué otras palabras la ponés y quién la está usando para designar a qué otro.
“Los griegos decían ‘necrópolis’, la ciudad de los muertos. Después dijeron ‘cementerio’, que es dormitorio, que es un eufemismo por morir es como dormir. Hoy en día tenemos la botánica, y entonces son todos jardines o parques. En algún punto dejamos de saber que cementerio quiere decir dormitorio, para nosotros es el lugar donde están los muertos, y entonces nos corremos al parque. Siempre va a pasar eso: la lengua se mueve, y en el punto en el que no queremos escuchar algo aparece el nuevo eufemismo.”
“Las metáforas de la vida cotidiana,” de Lakof y Johnson. Hay muchas metáforas que nos sirven para relacionarnos con la realidad y con las cosas, y algunas de esas metáforas son prejuiciosas y son ofensivas para ciertos grupos y pueden ser discriminadoras y hay que trabajarlas también. Por ejemplo, el negro y el blanco: eso es constitutivo de las culturas, son metáforas muy arraigadas, cuando algo está oscuro es negro y uno no ve, y hay muchas otras situaciones en las que se usa y parece que esté cargado. Pero no se puede expurgar todo. Hay valores que comportan la claridad y la luz (la luz es vida, es calor) y la oscuridad es lo contrario, pero
En los discursos públicos es necesario cuidarse.
Los manuales periodísticos fuera de la Argentina tienen advertencias sobre racismo o sexismo. Los manuales están para llamar la atención sobre ciertos usos, pero lo que hay que revisar son las prácticas que están detrás.
Las palabras discriminan casi por naturaleza: están para poner matiz, para juzgar, para distinguir. Pero yo puedo usar la palabra como un arma arrojadiza o para tender un puente.
“Los alemanes son perfectos para la organización: mirá qué bien les salió Treblinka”. Uno puede ver también el revés de la trama.
El estereotipo en un punto sirve para vincularse la realidad: uno no puede tener un vínculo con la realidad no mediado por lenguaje. Hay estereotipos que son productivos, que nos sirven para entender rápido una situación. El prejuicio es una manera de relacionarse con lo desconocido, y eso nos viene a veces de las historias que nos cuentan de chicos, de los cuentos de hadas, estereotipos como el zorro o el lobo. Están para enseñarles cosas a los chicos, y los chicos aprenden a vincularse con la realidad de cierto modo. No se puede erradicar los prejuicios, pero se puede ver qué prejuicios son perniciosos o siniestros y trabajarlos en el aula – si los chicos vuelven a sus casas y la familia es prejuiciosa, no hay mucho que se pueda hacer al respecto.
Cuanta más responsabilidad, o más visibilidad, tenga la persona, más cargo hay que hacerse de lo que hay detrás de la palabra.
Embajadora no quería decir ‘mujer que está a cargo de una embajada’ sino ‘esposa del embajador’, ‘gobernanta’ no es lo mismo que ‘gobernante’, el femenino muchas veces tiene que ver con tareas hogareñas o cargos menores mientras que el masculino tiene que ver con la cosa pública. Pero si queremos hablar de verdad ataquemos el problema de fondo y generemos oportunidades iguales

3.4.11

Where the streets actually have no name

U2’s 360° Tour in La Plata will blow you away – if you only get to hear it right


You may have seen videos and photos of The Claw, the centrepiece of U2’s  360° tour, and yet they do not prepare you for standing in the presence of the first wave of the Martian invasion. It is massive. I mean, truly massive, the legs spanning the width of a soccer pitch, its spire as tall as the arena that houses it. And La Plata’s Estadio Único is the perfect landing site – with or without U2, the rising curves and overarching canopy already give the place an outlandish feel, like it too has been brought from another planet.
And the band harps on the alien theme with its classic irony: the band walks on stage on top of David Bowie’s Space Oddity and walks out to the chorus of Elton John’s Rocket Man, and there are videos in between sets with cartoonish spaceships. The same irony that created The Claw: if you cannot hide the rig that is going to hold the lights and sound gear on top of a circular stage, hide it in plain sight by shoving it in the faces of the audience – make it so massive that it becomes the identity of the tour.
But the true cosmic event is the way in which Bono & co. take half a century of arena rock evolution, turn it on its head, run it through a blender and then amp it up to a factor of one million. It is the most spectacular rock show on Earth – a scripted, choreographed and utterly designed event in which every effect, movement, visual, prop and sound has been engineered for maximum effect. The experience is truly all around you: lights flood the stage in impossible configurations from all corners of the Claw, but they also project on the audience, turning the field into a sea of coloured heads and arms, the seats into giant screens for a light show that makes the experience unique.
U2 plays an arena the way Jimi Hendrix played a Stratocaster, and it sets them in a category of their own. David Bowie brought cabaret onto the stage, but he never really took it all the way. Peter Gabriel trademarked the concept show, but he leaves all the fun and concept on the stage. The Rolling Stones pump you harder, but they plant a bomb in front of you and let it explode. You may have seen better bands, more inspired musicians, more energetic shows, momentous tours that make the history books of rock music, but you will not live through something as engaging and engorging as this.
And they’ve been working on it for 20 years: Rattle & Hum (1987) chronicles the Joshua Tree tour, when U2 peaked their potential as a rock quartet and parted ways with the classic rock band. Four years later they greeted a new decade with a new album (Achtung Baby), a new self (a postmodern multimedia sensory overload) and a new tour to make it all happen (ZooTV). Since then, they have one-upped themselves on each world outing, always pushing the envelope one inch further, testing the borders, turning utopias into goldmines, repeating the music (the setlist goes all the way back to their first albums, with songs like Gloria, New Year’s Day, Sunday Bloody Sunday or I Will Follow) but never the ride – and, like the theme song to TV series United States of Tara goes, “I know we’ll be just fine if we learn to love the ride.”

A four-stroke engine. But in the middle of the multimedia explosion, just beneath the giant round TV screen that turns their faces into humongous icons, are four Irish guys (The Edge was actually born in England, but who’s counting), just flesh and blood singing, strumming and banging on metal and wood through a few truckloads of electronics. If they get to be blown into titans it must be because they have something titanic in the first place.
And they do. They have the songs, in the first place: while their albums may be uneven and sometimes patchy, U2 has enough solid gold songs to fill a lot more than the 160 minutes they play on this tour. Indeed, they could play many shows in many different textures, making them sound like different bands: the rockers, the lovers, the ravers, the melancholy gazers, the pick-you-ups, the mellow-you-downs. Deciding what to play, with a band like them, means more than anything making hard choices about what not to play.
Their setlist last Wednesday kicked off with a combo blow to the head: Even Better than the Real Thing, I Will Follow, Get On Your Boots, Magnificent and Misterious Ways light a mighty fuse that explodes in Elevation segueing into Until the End of the World. Then they brought it down with I Still Haven’t Found What I’m Looking For, picket it up two songs later with Beautiful Day, only to cool it with In a Little While. City of Blinding LightsVertigo, Sunday Bloody Sunday and Where The Streets Have No Name (sung in La Plata, a city whose streets actually don’t) got you jumping and pumping fists; One, Miss Sarajevo and With or Without You mellowed the affair, and so the rollercoaster went.
But the songs are propelled by a four-stroke engine as tight and powerful as an F1 racer. Bono is the ultimate frontman, an effective singer that excels at coming across to 58,000 people at once, lifting and soothing and wowing them at will, a presence bigger than the Claw and louder than the blaring sound. The Edge is the most underestimated of the guitarists that redefined the role of the guitar in rock music: while not a virtuoso, his echoes and delays and infinite effects squeeze the six strings for sounds they never thought they had in them, and the misterious way in which he weaves from rhythm to lead to noise to melody justifies Bono describing him on stage as “a man who is everywhere at the same time, and always somewhere interesting.¨ Adam Clayton’s bass and Larry Mullen Jr.’s drums are the unsung heroes providing the rock-solid foundation for the fanfare to stand on. Proof? Before the band walked on stage a crew member started playing a few bass lines from the songs to test the sound, and that was enough to turn  the crowd on, as recognizable as the tunes themselves, and the same could be said of Mullen’s beats.
the 180° tour. And yet, there was an Achilles heel to Wednesday’s show. A pretty big one, if you ask me.
The tour is named 360°, but not all degrees were created equal inside the Estadio Único. The Claw stands not at the centre of the pitch but at one of its ends, which creates the illusion of a traditional set with an open backstage more than a perfect circle – and the band’s efforts to walk around the outer ring that surrounded the inner circle of the stage still did not alter the fact that, for a considerable amount of time, the backbenchers had a view of Bono’s bum.
That could be spun into a defining feature: the fun of  360° is that you get to choose from many concert experiences, either a conventional one (augmented by the massive spaceship in front of you) on the pitch, or a truly upclose ride in the inner circle (where the band hovers over and around you on rotating bridges), or a panoramic one on the sides of the stadium. Choose your poison, as they go.
But for any of that to work, everyone must get decent sound. And last Wednesday, for a considerable chunk of the stadium, the sound quality was, to use a technical term, crap. Not Phil Spector’s wall of sound, but a ball of sound – a gooey, sticky, fuzzy ball. While the best show on Earth rolled in front of your eyes, where I sat (front right of the stage, on the sides, if you want to know) it felt like I was listening to it through a cheap radio blaring out.
The Claw booms mightily from towers of speakers on all four sides, but somehow the engineers had not compensated for the compounded echo of the three sides standing dangerously close to the sonic death trap of the stands and ceiling bouncing back the music, and the tsunami of waves resulted in the aforementioned ball. Bad for the distinct, precise, delicate balance of U2, but absolutely deathly for the power rock of supporting act Muse, which got to my ears as loud distorted gravel where voice equalled guitar equalled whatever else. Literally, the singer was talking between songs and I couldn’t make out the words.
Friends in front of the stage reported to bad sound but not as bad as what I got, while out photographer standing at the inner circle says it sounded just fine. Images on TV report that the mixing board heard a choir of rock angels, and I am looking forward to a TV broadcast to see what sound experience the lads had in mind as they were playing.
Fellow members of the press told me that the shows in Santiago de Chile sounded absolutely perfect, and the sound engineers (if they want to keep their job, at least) will no doubt get the sliders and knobs tuned just right for tomorrow and Sunday. I just hope they had got them right on Wednesday’s sound check.
But that minor distraction did bring to mind a hazard of  U2 on stage: in a show that pushes the envelope so much, that is so minutely architectured, it only takes the slightest distraction from the thrill of the ride (like a grating roar of pebbles à la Matthew Arnold in your ears in my case) to highlight the edge of over-the-top just a hair’s width away. But the nyou get back on the train and have the ride of your life.
Buenos Aires Herald, 31/3/2011

23.2.11

A Modest Proposal Revisited: Teaching English in the Real World

En un comentario al post anterior, alguien me pedía el texto de un artículo mío de hace ya varios años. Aquí está. 

EFL ‘Howl’

I have seen the best teachers of my generation lying on a classroom floor, their lessons bleeding, their mind faltering, their methodology scattered over the desks where thirty-odd unmotivated students chatter, work on their homework for other subjects and make plans for the next weekend. I have seen them try "affective learning" and humanistic activities with a group of teenagers who wanted nothing out of the subject but a passing mark, and who interpreted their "heart-to-heart" approach as a sign of lack of control over the classroom and started a full-scale riot. I have seen them struggling to get a grip on themselves while repeating to themselves the mantra “misbehaviour is only a symptom of lack of motivation and communication”, their self esteem oozing out of their pores every time the phrase is uttered. I have seen them poring over books with titles like "Get the best out of your students through yoga exercises and subconscious tapping", "A multicultural approach to the teaching of language skills" and "Drama, poetry, dancing, chanting and prancing in the language classroom". I have seen them, and myself, try all this in a state secondary school where the students are unmotivated, the tape recorder does not work, a VCR is a utopia, discipline is non-existent, teaching of other subjects is almost Victorian (Dickensian, I should say, thinking of "Hard Times" and Mrs Wopsle in "Great Expectations") and the pay is short of a pittance. I have seen them try and fail, only to try again in the following lesson. I have seen their best intentions crumble as their discouragement rises. I have seen their despair, their frustration, their relentless effort leading nowhere.
I have seen this, and I have said to myself “somewhere along the line, something has gone wrong”. Something must be done to help real teachers in real classrooms. Something to avoid their turning to the “tried and tested recipes” other teachers resort to - threaten students with low grades or extra homework, treat them as juvenile delinquents, create an atmosphere of terror through displays of power, use psychological (and even in some cases physical) violence. Something to bridge the gap between belief and practice. Something to allow teachers to do their best teaching.

Howling down

My poor imitation of Allen Ginsberg aside, a quick browse through a professional library will show that most books were written by teachers who work in small schools with highly motivated students who travel to England for the sole reason of attending a language course. These teachers (who usually work at only one place with reasonable timetables and an equally reasonable salary) have resources that overworked and underpaid teachers in the “real world” envision only in dreams: computers, libraries, administrative staff, a group of colleagues in the same circumstances willing to work as a team, opportunities (very often paid) for reflection and professional development and, most of all, time. By the same token, those teachers will rarely face a class of more than 12 students, and if they do, those students will be strongly motivated. What is more, their students will be doing nothing but learning English: there will be no other subjects in the curriculum, few other concerns in their minds.
Needless to say, the predominant teaching reality in the rest of the teaching world is far from what has been described in the previous paragraph, if not the opposite. Teachers have to face large classes of students who have as little as three weekly periods of language teaching squeezed in between ten other subjects. Classes in which, in many cases, discipline and motivation are foreign notions. Classes which take as much as five minutes to quiet down and as little as five seconds to return to a state of chaos. Classes in which students will be more interested in doing a last-minute review for their coming Mathematics test than in reading an article about their favourite rock band or preparing a poster describing their neighbourhood- let alone listening to a taped radio programme about the history of the Volkswagen Beetle. Yet the teacher, overworked and underpaid as s/he is, spends Saturday mornings (and a substantial amount of his/her meagre salary and free time) at seminars by or about what the teachers mentioned in the previous paragraph have produced. Attending such seminars, or simply perusing the literature on the same subject, may at times approach an exercise in utopian visualisation, and at best feels like driving a Ferrari in a shanty town: the streets are much rougher than those the car was designed for, and the vehicle is likely to be vandalised the minute it gets out of the garage. It just does not work. Not because there is something inherently wrong with the ideas, but because they have emerged from a different teaching reality.

A modest proposal

Based on what I said before, I strongly believe it is essential to select a corpus of “Real World methodology", a selection of material that supports those teaching in schools where conditions are far from adequate (i. e., anyone working in public and some sectors of private education, be it in Argentina, Brazil, the UK or Japan), material bringing real help for real situations in real classrooms. Material which, rather than reinvent psychology, addresses classroom situations. Material written by people with chalk-white (or marker-black) fingers, people who have been there, done that and reflected on it.
Participating on Internet discussion lists brought my attention to the fact that far-from-ideal teaching conditions are not exclusive to Latin America, as I had first thought, but seem to be the reality of schools all over the world. This makes the proposal, if anything, more urgent. It also highlights the extent to which teachers discredit themselves by submitting to the dictums of academia: home-grown ideas, useful and valuable as they may be, seem to lose all value when opposed to the flashy, five-syllabled, chart-and-graphed, pseudo-scientific, highly abstract writings of the guru-like “credited authorities in ELT”.
Teacher trainers seem especially prone to being seduced by the glamorous gurus. Most students leaving teacher training colleges these days (i. e., the future professionals) seem to be under the impression that methodology and teaching are divorced. They cannot be blamed for thinking so if they have devoted more class time to the discussion of suggestopaedia and the silent way than to class management and control. They cannot be blamed if they have been trained in using rather than creating and authoring material. And they cannot be blamed, either, for turning their backs on public education in search of an environment in which they find better working conditions, if they have not been prepared (or encouraged) to deal with the challenges that public education involves.
Reversing this situation, however, is not half as hard as it sounds. The tools are readily available- a few books, some minds, some will to change. It may involve as little as selecting a collection of articles and titles and passing it on to other colleagues so that the list grows with the recommendations of as many teachers as possible. It may mean adapting some theories or approaches to our reality and making these variations known to other teachers. It may mean producing some material and even some theory, or summarising and processing existing theory. It may mean getting involved in Action Research and professional exchanges. What it does not mean is providing teachers with a collection of “recipes”. Nothing could be further from my thoughts. There is nothing more practical than a sound theory; there is nothing as useless as a bunch of recipes. I propose a grassroots, hands-on approach which, far from spoonfeeding teachers or preaching on what can and cannot be done in a classroom, provides teachers with tools for reflecting on their teaching reality. I am drawing attention to the need for more Action Research and creative work, and for the sharing of this work among as large a group of teachers as possible. If anything, I am asking teachers to assume their role as professionals of language teaching rather than VCR technicians who can fix and adapt what other people designed but cannot build an operating model all for themselves.

So far... (The Road Ahead)

Teachers rarely suggest each other things they wouldn’t try themselves, yet when one reads the latest methodology books the reaction is often “That would never work”, “I would never do something like that” or (perhaps the most discouraging of all) “That would be great but I have not got the time and/or resources”. The place where most of the change I am envisioning will take place is the staff room, over a cup of coffee. A few teachers with a few minutes in between lessons exchange information which I have found to be more valuable and sensible than most things books teach: “I have done that exercise, but I have changed...”, “You may try this technique I have found somewhere and which has worked well with my students”, “Is anyone interested in this article/video segment/activity I found...?”, “In my experience, that does not work because...”, “That’s a good idea; however, I would also...”. Given the right staff and the right attitude, much will come out of very little. But, most important of all, what other teachers will suggest will always come from experience, and not from the latest theory or as a way of supporting the point an author is making.
Other changes will have to take place where the seed becomes a bud: at teacher training courses. I will be so bold as to mention my own experience. A few months ago I was offered a teaching position at a teacher training college. Its title, “Visual Aids and Multimedia in ELT”, was challenging, and a number of decisions had to be made. At one end lied a semiology-based course on media studies with glimpses of language acquisition theory, a bit of neuro linguistic programming and the like. At the other end, the ever-present temptation of reviewing published material, handing out a bunch of recipes showing “how I go about it” and then “try to do the same in your classroom, thank you very much, goodbye”. Neither option would have been satisfactory: the first would have filled the students with useless data and half-baked ideas that would not have taken them one step closer to becoming better teachers; the latter would have meant transmitting tips and recipes, but would leave them in the lurch when push came to shove and they had to prepare their own lessons. The most realistic, practical and committed solution (at least the one I could come up with) was basing the course on a relative lack of theory and an absence of recipes, and as much common sense and creativity as thirty trainees (all of them working as teachers already) could muster. I also made a point of not doing anything in class that trainees would not be able to do in a real teaching environment, with real students and real timing. So far, this has meant asking them to prepare activities and account for them (building their own theory as they do so), sharing their ideas, criticising each other’s work, as well as adding and contributing to it. Some months (plus a few strikes and bank holidays) after the beginning of our weekly lessons, I have found this approach to go a long way, with new and exciting ideas being produced almost every meeting (some of them similar to the ones found in the literature on the subject, others which to the best of my knowledge are new) and, most important of all, with the students developing a critical, hands-on attitude rather than good reading habits.
These are just two ideas in the direction of what I believe would be a positive change. Time, trial and error will tell if these are the right steps or not. Whatever the path chosen, however, it is clear that something must be done to bridge the gap between the theory we look up to and the reality we go through. Otherwise, all the things which are available to more privileged students (in schools of English, in private lessons, taking ESP courses in their offices) will never be available to those who cannot afford to pay extra. Otherwise, we will be failing in our mission as teachers, which is to bring the best of our knowledge to all of our students.

12.1.11

What else is to be alive?

Free and uncompromising, María Elena Walsh created a world of her own that lives on


Writer and singer María Elena Walsh died yesterday morning in Buenos Aires after battling hard and long the bone cancer she first been diagnosed with in 1981. When the news hit TV broadcasts, around midday, my wife and I had a pang of sorrow and then a knee-jerk reaction: switch the channel so our 5-year-old daughter wouldn’t find out so bluntly that the woman she calls “my friend María Elena Walsh” was gone.
It is not because she was a frequent visitor to our home – in fact, by the time my daughter was born Walsh had already retired from the scarce public life she had. But María Elena Walsh has been (and will remain) a strong presence in my daughter’s life, just as she had been in her father’s and even her grandparents’: she has been listening to Walsh’s songs ever since she was born, and when she was 2 we started our bedtime reading sessions with her Cuentopos de Gulubú (before her third birthday, she could recite her favourite story, Don Fresquete, almost by heart, and we have gone through the novel Dailán Kifki three times already, always at her bequest). This Christmas, Santa brought her baby brother a DVD with CGI clips of her songs – the baby is interested enough, but she is the one begging for three and even four daily repeats.
She is not alone in her fandom: artists, officials and personalities across the board and the Spanish-speaking world lamented María Elena Walsh’s passing yesterday, and not only for her children’s  songs, poems and stories, but for the music and literature she dedicated to adults, with anthems like Como la cigarra, Serenata municipal, Oración a la Justicia, Canción para la tierra de uno or Dame la mano y vamos ya taking a well-deserved spot next to classics like La tortuga Manuelita, El reino del Revés and La Reina Batata (songs which, in turn, go well beyond the realm of bland kiddie fodder and include strong political overtones in defense of freedom, pacifism and the right to be oneself).
She had that rare quality (born of talent, determination and fierce work ethics) that allowed her to bridge both worlds: she brought surrealism, European cabaret and Lido-style varieté to the moralized stiffness of children entertainment, and in turn brought the florid yet fluid style of her writing (equally rooted in modernism and the traditions both of Spanish Siglo de oro poetry and folk poetry and music, of which she was an avid collector and consummate performer) to the adult world.
María Elena Walsh was born in 1930. “My parents and my grandfather on my mother’s side were Argentine. My other grandparents: Andalousian, English and Republican Irish,” she wrote in Cuento de la autora, her own life story explained for her children fans included in the book Chaucha y Palito. In this delicious and honest account, she describes a childhood lived in a middle-class suburban home that was “very big, with a garden, patios, fruit trees, a henhouse, dog, cat, canaries, turtle, bicycles, books and a piano. What more can you ask?” Her first literary loves were Dickens, Perrault, Jules Verne and Lewis Carroll, as well as limericks and nursery rhymes (two popular English traditions that she would masterfully bring into Argentine literature through her writings).
She had many artistic lives, and the first started very early on: at the age of 15, she had already published poems in the newspaper La Nación and the magazine El Hogar, and “two years later, in 1947, encouraged by some writers I had known through those publications, I emptied a book-shaped piggy bank where my parents had saved coins and small change for me and paid for the printing of a book of poetry: Otoño imperdonable (Unforgiveable Autumn).”  The book was well-received, and earned praise from the likes of Pablo Neruda and Juan Ramón Jiménez, who offered their home in the US as a sort of writer’s retreat for the teenage María Elena. She would later refer to her relationship with the Spanish master in mixed terms, a generous yet fierceful figure that would cast an imposing shadow on her writing.
When she returned to Argentina, during the Perón years, she did not feel at ease: “Young people, like myself, students and intellectuals, rejected the lack of freedom and rebelled any way we could. And, as cyclically happens in Argentina, we felt like taking off,” she writes. She travelled to Europe with singer and companion Leda Valladares, and in Paris they would form a successful folk duo performing the music Valladares had compiled in her trips around Argentina‘s North-East. They recorded two albums in Europe, and became a regular feature at the Crazy Horse cabaret. In the late 50s, they returned to Argentina to travel the Andes, compiling music and recording two albums that would foreground these hidden cultural gems to broader audiences. Meanwhile, she started to write poems and songs for children. “It’s only when you’re far away that you better fall in love with your home. The mother land is loved and yearned for like childhood is, and maybe for this, for this nostalgia, for this need to play in my own language once again, I started writing rhymes for children,” she explained to her younger readers.
When she returned to Argentina she compiled those poems in Tutú Marambá, and in 1962 she set music to some of them and premièred Canciones para mirar at the San Martín theatre. That show, a varieté for children often revisited by performers to this day, transformed the scene and turned her career around for good, and the album where she recorded the music (with Valladares for the last time) remains a classic. It was followed by Doña Disparate y Bambuco, another timeless play.
As children testify half a century later, and as all artists in the genre acknowledge, María Elena Walsh is the non plus ultra of children’s music and theatre. Her infinite imagination, the seemingly effortless magic of her puns and verbal twists, her endearing characters, her profound understanding of what makes kids tick and how
In the late 60s she returned to the “adult” music world with Juguemos en el mundo, offering a brilliant spin on the trendy protest song. With commitments closer to the human than the political (peace, equality, freedom, the pangs of exile, the follies and injustice of modern life), she used razor-sharp irony, her deep knowledge of the cabaret world and folk music and a peerless sensitivity to create songs at once beautiful, hard-hitting and loaded with a brand of humour that spoke of her Anglo heritage.
Still, the message was so loud and clear enough that, when the military took power in  the 1976 coup, Walsh was one of the bravest, most vocal personalities to denounce the atrocities and censorship of the times. The pressure on her was such that she gave up music and live performances in 1978. Still, because she did it with the oblique slice of a Swift rather than the blunt force of a protester, some knuckleheads in the so-called “progressive/intellectual” circles labelled her a mild, compromising figure. Some people are just too blind to see beyond their noses, if that they see.
The rest of her life was devoted to writing fiction and memoirs, both for children and adults. A living legend, she still reserved the right to speak her mind (even if her opinion was bound to be unpopular) and be as recluse as she wanted – she had a well-developed distrust of artistic backstabbing circles and the press. Her last book was Fantasmas en el parque (2008), where she made her first open and explicit reference to her homosexuality and her 30-year relationship with photographer Sara Facio.
As for myself, my two María Elena moments were, I must confess, botched. I saw her at the lobby of a hotel in Montevideo in 1998, and went to greet her in awe – I’ve never been that starstruck and inarticulate. Still, she was gracious even at a check-in desk with her luggage still unpacked, and I got her autograph (the only one I’ve ever asked for) on her personal Manuelita stationery.
A year ago, the Herald was inches away from getting an interview with Walsh, but her weak condition took a turn for the worse and the meeting was cancelled, literally, at the last minute. Before leaving home I asked my daughter if she had any messages she would like me to pass on to the author of some of her favourite stories and songs: “Tell her I love her very much,”  she said. I never had the nerve to tell her the interview had been cancelled because María Elena was ill and in pain.
Like a friend wrote on Facebook, in my house María Elena Walsh lives on: every night, at bedtime, her unparallelled writing comes to life and brings smiles on me and my children. When they grow up, they will discover new sides of her to keep them company, and rediscover the old ones when they become parents themselves. What else is to be alive, can anyone be more alive than that?
Buenos Aires Herald, 11/1/11

27.8.10

La birome de la muerte


El combo sarmientino "Con la espada, con la pluma y la palabra" reducido a un solo producto: los tactical pens. Biromes de metal hiperresistente que supuestamente aguantan lo que sea, cargan cartuchos de Fisher Space Pen (de tinta presurizada, escriben en cualquier condición) y se promueven además como armas improvisadas de último recurso (capaces de apuñalar, algunas muestran videos de pruebas en las que se usan para romper vidrios). 
Este párrafo es la introducción a la página de uno de los fabricantes: 
From Marines hunting terrorists in burning deserts, SAR expeditions in bone chilling mountains, SWAT officers executing high risk warrant service, EMTs functioning in extreme conditions, or a civilian working in a non-permissive environment. All of these special operations groups have something in common - they all require a pen that they can depend on.
(De marines cazando terroristas en desiertos ardientes, a expediciones del SAR en montañas que congelan hasta los huesos, a agentes de SWAT ejecutando tareas de servicio de altísimo riesgo, a paramédicos trabajando en condiciones extremas, o a un civil trabajando en un ambieente hostil. Todas estas operaciones especiales tienen algo en común: todas requieren de una lapicera en la que se pueda confiar.)
Se venden en Estados Unidos en las armerías, supongo que acá también. ¿Quiénes las compran? Locos como el protagonista de este comentario de Amazon.com para un modelo fabricado por (redoble de tambores) Smith & Wesson:
A friend of mine bought this pen after a female coworker was promoted over him. He wasn't feeling confident in myself - was listless, depressed, tired all of the time - just felt like crap about himself. There were a few things he could do about that - but he decided to buy something since that's so much easier than working out, going to school, etc. He had the options down to either this pen, an attack dog, a new truck or a gun. Of these options the pen was a hell of a deal - just 10% the cost of a cheap gun or dog plus few maintenance costs. 
The pen that he received is really great - it has excellent balance, girth and heft. You can definitely punch it through things (like cardboard boxes). He don't really write, so he don't have much of an opinion about how well it writes, but it's fun to hold. 
Sometimes when his coworker/now manager ("Jane") is talking he thinks it feels good to just keep his hand on his pen in his pocket. He feels that it gives him a greater sense of power.
(Un amigo mío se compró esta lapicera cuando ascendieron a una compañera de trabajo por sobre él. No se sentía seguro de sí mismo  - estaba bajoneado, deprimido, cansado todo el tiempo - tenía la autoestima por el piso. Podía hacer algunas cosas al respecto - pero decidió comprarse algo, ya que eso es mucho más fácil que hacer ejercicio, estudiar, etc. Redujo las opciones a esta birome, un perro de ataque, una camioneta nueva o un arma. Entre estas opciones, la birome fue flor de ganga: apenas un 10% del costo de un arma o un perro baratos, y menos gastos de mantenimiento.
La lapicera que compró es realmente buenísima: tiene excelente balance, diámetro y peso. Definitivamente se pueden hacer agujeros en cosas (como cajas de cartón). El en realidad no escribe, por lo que no tiene mucho que opinar acerca de qué tan bien escribe esta birome, pero es divertida de tener en la mano.
A veces, cuando está hablando su colega/ahora gerente ("Juana"), él cree que se siente mejor sólo por tener sus manos sobre su birome en el bolsillo. Siente que le da una mayor sensación de poder.")
Considerando que "Buck Nuggets", el autor del comentario, escribió sólo una más sobre una novela que parece ser un chiste para graduados de Letras diciendo "leéla sólo si tenés karma para tirar al techo o si te gustan las metáforas berretas y abundantes- como los bifes de un tenedor libre chino", me inclino a pensar que es uan joda. Pero, en lo que a jodas se refiere, es mejor que unos cuantos cuentos del supuesto realismo duro. Este comentario tendría los aplausos de la noche en más de una lectura de NNA.
Y otra función para estas biromes: todos los que encaran la escritura como la guerra y salen al mundo como a un campo de batalla, o de guerrilla, o de espionaje, que escriban con este engendro. Yo me quedo con mi Parker 51. 

17.5.10

"Me estás robando" "Ya lo sé, pero soy un niño"

Daniel Alarcón y una crónica maravillosa acerca del mundo milagrero de la edición pirata de edición de libros en Perú, que por momentos da ganas de llorary por momentos de reír y por momentos de irse a Lima a hacer un curso de edición popular económica y marketing callejero.


En un cable te Télam, dos minutos después, estos párrafos intrigantes:
Cerca de un millón de internautas chinos se ganan la vida publicando novelas y relatos con gran demanda por parte del público, infomó hoy el diario China Daily. 
Webs especializadas en la publicación de estas obras cobran a los lectores que quieren acceder a ellas, aunque los precios son hasta diez veces más bajos que los de las ediciones en papel, y después entregan entre un 50 y un 70 por ciento de lo recolectado a los escritores. 
‘Destello‘, uno de los nuevos escritores en línea comentó que ‘los autores son contratados para escribir al día un determinado número de palabras, y suelen emplear entre seis y diez horas diarias en este trabajo‘. 
 O tempora, o mores...

14.5.10

Al pan, pan, y al ciego, ciego

Dice la National Federation for the Blind de Estados Unidos en una resolución de 2001: "We believe that it is respectable to be blind, and although we have no particular pride in the fact of our blindness, neither do we have any shame in it. To the extent that euphemisms are used to convey any other concept or image, we deplore such use. We can make our own way in the world on equal terms with others, and we intend to do it." (Creemos que es respetable ser ciego, y aunque no estamos particularmente orgullosos de nuestra ceguera tampoco sentimos ningún tipo de vergüenza acerca de ella. En tanto que lso eufemismos se usen para transmitir cualquier otro concepto o imagen, deploramos su uso. Podemos abrirnos camino por nuestra cuenta en el mundo en iguales condiciones a los demás, y pensamos hacerlo.)  


En versión Violencia Rivas: ¡metete la corrección política en el culo!

11.5.10

De qué vive un escritor

Neil Gaiman escribe un pequeño tratado sobre la autonomía de la literatura y el arte en la era de su reproductibilidad técnica mientras explica su parte en un escandalete sobre por que cobró -y donó- 45.000 dólares de un fondo público para dar una charla de dos horas en una biblioteca, problema que en la Argentina nadie difícilmente tenga porque a) casi nadie cobra esa plata por ese tipo de cosas, b) los que cobran esa plata por ese tipo de cosas siempre se la cobran al Estado, cosa que ya dejó de escandalizarnos (por lo menos hasta que Faillace anuncie el Top 40 de Frankfurt y ahí nos rasgamos las vestiduras nuevamente).
(I don’t like talking about how much money I make, because I spent enough years as a starving journalist to know what it’s like not to have money, and to envy or resent those who do. But if you’re wondering how I can afford to blithely wave goodbye to a fee like that: I make my money writing. I sell a lot of books, in dozens of countries around the world, every year. I write and occasionally co-produce movies, and I sell the film rights to my books and stories. The Graveyard Book spent over a year on the New York Times Bestseller List.Instructions came out this week, and went straight in at #4. There were months last year when I had four different books on the New York Times Bestseller Lists at the same time. Like I said, I’m a writer, and I get paid for my writing.)
Algo así como: No me gusta hablar de cuánto gano, porque pasé suficientes años siendo un periodista muerto de hambre como para saber cómo es no tener dinero, y envidiar o guardarle rencor a los que sí lo tienen. Pero por si se preguntan cómo me puedo permitir desprenderme tan alegremente de una suma semejante: gano mi dinero escribiendo. Vendo un montón de libros, en docenas de países alrededor del mundo, todos los años. Escribo y a veces co-produzco películas, y vendo los derechos para llevar a la pantalla mis libros e historias. "The Graveyard Book" pasó más de un año en la lista de más vendidos del New York times. "Instructions" salió esta semana, y arrancó directamente en el puesto 4. Hubo meses el año pasado en los que tuve cuatro libros distintos al mismo tiempo en la lista de los más vendidos del New York Times. Como les dije, soy un escritor, y me pagan por lo que escribo.